Blog

The Real Cost of 911 Non-Compliance: Fines, Lawsuits, and Liability

Fines, lawsuits, remediation, and reputational damage: what 911 non-compliance really costs, and what the Kari's Law Reporting Act would change.

May 12, 2026

Reading time

Product

Everyone knows 911 compliance is required. Fewer people know what happens when you're not compliant.

The short answer: it's expensive, and the spotlight is growing. In April 2026, the U.S. House passed the Kari's Law Reporting Act (H.R. 5201) by a 405–5 vote. If it becomes law, the FCC would have to report publicly on how well phone system manufacturers and vendors are following Kari's Law. But regulators are only one source of exposure. Non-compliance also creates civil liability, operational disruption, and reputational damage.

Here's what 911 non-compliance actually costs.

The Regulatory Penalties

The FCC has authority to impose forfeitures (fines) for violations of Kari's Law and Ray Baum's Act. The penalty structure is straightforward but adds up quickly.

FCC penalties are $10,000 per violation

A "violation" isn't one phone that can't reach 911. It's each instance of non-compliance. If your system prevents direct 911 dialing across 50 phones, that's potentially 50 violations. If your location data is inaccurate for 200 users, that's 200 violations.

Plus $500 for each day the violation continues

Once you know about a violation and fail to fix it, each day of continued non-compliance adds to the total. A location data problem that persists for six months while you "work on a solution" compounds into significant additional liability.

Those numbers add up fast for any organization with hundreds of phones, especially when a problem goes unnoticed after a system change or office move.

In practice, the FCC typically doesn't pursue maximum penalties. But the statutory authority exists, and the exposure is real.

The Kari's Law Reporting Act: What It Would Do

Many organizations have treated 911 compliance as a theoretical risk, on the assumption that no one is actively checking. A bill now moving through Congress is a sign that assumption is getting harder to hold.

On April 21, 2026, the House passed the Kari's Law Reporting Act (H.R. 5201) by a vote of 405–5 (House roll call 127). As of October 2026, the bill is with the Senate Commerce Committee and is not yet law. As passed by the House, it would direct the FCC to publish a report within 180 days of enactment on how well multi-line telephone system (MLTS) manufacturers and vendors are complying with Kari's Law (bill text). It isn't a new regulation. It's an accountability check on the rule that already exists.

What the report would cover

The report would cover the extent of manufacturer and vendor compliance, the obstacles to compliance, and the FCC's recommendations. It is aimed at the companies that make and sell phone systems, not at the organizations that run them. But the underlying question, whether systems allow direct 911 dialing and on-site notification, is the same one your own system has to answer.

Why it matters for your organization

If the bill becomes law and the report finds widespread gaps, expect more attention on the systems those vendors sold, from regulators, insurers, and your own legal counsel. Organizations that can already document their compliance will be in a much better position than those that have to scramble.

The Civil Liability

Regulatory fines are predictable. Lawsuits are not.

When a 911 call fails and someone is harmed, the organization operating the phone system faces potential civil liability. These cases don't have statutory caps: damages are determined by the circumstances.

Wrongful death claims

If someone dies because 911 responders went to the wrong location or couldn't be reached at all, the organization may face a wrongful death lawsuit. Damages in these cases routinely reach seven figures, and settlements or verdicts can go much higher depending on the circumstances.

Personal injury claims

Non-fatal outcomes still create liability. Delayed response due to inaccurate location data, failed notification that prevented internal assistance, inability to reach 911 in an emergency, all of these can form the basis of personal injury claims.

Negligence arguments write themselves

Plaintiff's attorneys don't need to be creative when federal law explicitly requires direct 911 access and accurate location data, and the organization failed to provide either. The existence of Kari's Law and Ray Baum's Act establishes a clear standard of care. Failure to meet that standard is negligence almost by definition.

Insurance may not cover everything

General liability policies often have exclusions or sublimits for regulatory violations. Even if a policy covers the civil claim, the organization may be on the hook for fines, remediation costs, and legal fees that exceed coverage.

The Operational Costs

Getting caught non-compliant triggers immediate operational expenses beyond the penalties themselves.

Emergency remediation

When an audit or incident reveals compliance gaps, organizations typically scramble to fix them. Emergency projects cost more than planned implementations: expedited timelines, overtime, premium pricing for urgent vendor support. Organizations that work with a dedicated E911 compliance partner like 9Line avoid this entirely by getting it right from the start.

System replacement or upgrade

Sometimes the existing phone system can't be made compliant without significant changes. Organizations have been forced into unplanned capital expenditures to replace systems that couldn't meet requirements.

Ongoing monitoring requirements

Consent decrees and settlement agreements often include compliance monitoring provisions. The organization must demonstrate ongoing compliance through regular reporting, third-party audits, or both, all at their own expense.

Internal investigation costs

When something goes wrong, organizations typically conduct internal investigations to understand what happened and why. Legal counsel, technical consultants, and executive time all have costs.

The Reputational Impact

Compliance failures become public in multiple ways.

FCC enforcement actions are public record

When the FCC issues a citation, proposes a forfeiture, or enters a consent decree, the documents are publicly available. Industry publications cover significant enforcement actions. Your customers, partners, and competitors can see exactly what happened.

Lawsuits are public

Civil complaints are filed in court and become part of the public record. Even cases that settle often have public filings that describe the allegations in detail.

News coverage amplifies incidents

A failed 911 call with serious consequences often generates local news coverage. "Employee couldn't reach 911" is a story that writes itself. The organization's name is attached to that story permanently.

Customer and employee trust erodes

People expect 911 to work. When they learn their employer or service provider couldn't guarantee that basic safety function, trust diminishes. For organizations in regulated industries or those that emphasize safety culture, this reputational damage can affect business relationships and recruiting.

What Enforcement Looks Like

The FCC's largest 911 penalties to date have been against telecommunications carriers for 911 outages. Those cases involved service providers rather than enterprises, but they show the FCC is willing to impose substantial fines when 911 calls fail.

For organizations that operate their own phone systems, the bigger near-term risk is usually not an FCC fine. It's what happens after a failed or misdirected 911 call: an investigation, a lawsuit, and the question of why the system didn't meet a requirement that has been in place since 2020.

The Hidden Cost: Near Misses

Most compliance failures don't result in tragedy. Someone calls 911, the response is delayed or misdirected, but ultimately things work out. No one dies. No lawsuit follows.

These near misses are the most common outcome, and the most dangerous.

Near misses create false confidence

When a non-compliant system "works" most of the time, organizations assume they're fine. They delay remediation because nothing bad has happened yet. Each successful call despite the compliance gap reinforces the decision to defer action.

Near misses are still violations

The FCC doesn't require a tragedy before taking action. The violation exists whether or not someone was harmed. An audit or complaint can trigger enforcement regardless of outcomes.

Near misses accumulate

Every day a non-compliant system operates is another day of exposure. The continuing violation penalties keep running. The probability of a serious incident increases with each 911 call the system handles.

Organizations that wait for something bad to happen before addressing compliance are playing a dangerous game with compounding stakes. The right E911 partner eliminates the guesswork: 9Line helps organizations identify and close compliance gaps before a near miss becomes a headline.

The Cost of Compliance vs. Non-Compliance

Compliance has costs: technology, implementation, ongoing management. But those costs are predictable and controllable.

Non-compliance costs are unpredictable and potentially unlimited. A single serious incident can generate liability that dwarfs any reasonable compliance investment.

Consider the comparison:

Compliance investment:

  • E911 solution implementation: $10,000–$50,000 depending on size
  • Annual maintenance and updates: $5,000–$20,000
  • Staff time for location data management: Ongoing but manageable

Non-compliance exposure:

  • FCC penalties: $10,000 per violation, plus $500 for each day the violation continues
  • Civil liability: No cap, routinely six to seven figures
  • Emergency remediation: Premium costs for rushed implementation
  • Reputational damage: Unquantifiable but real

The math is clear. Compliance is the better investment. Solutions like 9Line make that investment predictable: a known cost that eliminates the unknowns.

What Organizations Should Do

If you're uncertain about your compliance status, the time to act is now, before a failed 911 call or an outside review answers the question for you. Here's where to start.

Assess your current state. Can every user dial 911 directly without a prefix? Does every 911 call deliver accurate location data? Is someone notified internally when a 911 call is placed?

Document your compliance. If you are compliant, prove it. Maintain records of your configuration, testing results, and location data management processes.

Fix gaps immediately. If you find issues, remediate them. Don't wait for a project budget or a convenient implementation window. The exposure exists today.

Implement ongoing management. Compliance isn't one-time. Location data must be maintained as people move and organizations change. Build processes that keep you compliant over time.

Partner with a compliance expert. Work with a specialist who understands the full scope of Kari's Law and RAY BAUM's Act and can get you to a documented, defensible compliance position quickly.

How 9Line Helps

9Line provides enterprise E911 solutions purpose-built for Kari's Law and RAY BAUM's Act compliance. Every feature maps directly to a requirement in the rules.

Direct 911 dialing. 9Line ensures every user on your multi-line telephone system can reach 911 without dialing a prefix, an access code, or any additional digits. That is the core requirement of Kari's Law.

Accurate dispatchable location. 9Line delivers precise, dispatchable location data with every 911 call (building, floor, wing, room) so first responders arrive at the right place. This satisfies Ray Baum's Act requirements and eliminates the location accuracy gaps that drive both FCC enforcement and civil liability.

On-site notification. When a 911 call is placed, 9Line automatically alerts designated on-site personnel (security teams, facilities managers, front desk staff) so your internal response can begin immediately, not after emergency services arrive. This is a Kari's Law requirement that many organizations overlook.

Ongoing location data management. Compliance isn't a one-time project. People move desks, floors get reconfigured, offices open and close. 9Line provides the tools and processes to keep location data accurate over time, so your compliance doesn't degrade the moment your initial deployment is complete.

Compliance audits and documentation. Not sure where you stand? 9Line can assess your current environment, identify gaps, and provide the documentation you need to demonstrate compliance, whether for your own records, your legal team, your insurers, or an FCC inquiry.

Federal rules have required direct dialing, notification, and dispatchable location for years. 9Line helps you prove you meet them, and stay that way.

Frequently asked questions

What are the FCC penalties for 911 non-compliance?

FCC penalties are $10,000 per violation, plus $500 for each day the violation continues. Each instance of non-compliance can count as a separate violation, so a system that blocks direct 911 dialing on 50 phones could mean 50 violations.

Can an organization be sued over a failed 911 call?

Yes. When a 911 call fails and someone is harmed, the organization operating the phone system can face wrongful death or personal injury claims, and those damages have no statutory cap. Kari's Law and RAY BAUM's Act establish a clear standard of care that plaintiffs can point to.

Does insurance cover 911 compliance failures?

Not always. General liability policies often have exclusions or sublimits for regulatory violations, and fines, remediation costs, and legal fees can exceed coverage.

Does the FCC need someone to be harmed before enforcing 911 rules?

No. A 911 compliance violation exists whether or not anyone was harmed, and an audit or complaint can trigger enforcement regardless of outcome.

How does the cost of E911 compliance compare with non-compliance?

Implementing an E911 solution typically costs $10,000 to $50,000 depending on organization size, plus $5,000 to $20,000 a year for maintenance. Non-compliance exposure includes FCC penalties of $10,000 per violation plus $500 for each day the violation continues, along with uncapped civil liability.

The Bottom Line

911 non-compliance is expensive. Fines, lawsuits, remediation costs, and reputational damage can easily reach seven figures for a single serious incident. And with Congress now pressing the FCC for a public report on Kari's Law compliance, scrutiny is more likely to increase than decrease.

Compliance costs money too. But it's a fraction of the alternative, and it's entirely within your control.

The organizations that take 911 seriously don't do it because of the penalties. They do it because keeping people safe is the right thing to do. The fact that it also protects the organization from catastrophic liability is just a bonus.

The cost of compliance is predictable. The cost of non-compliance is not. If you need a partner, 9Line is ready to help.

See Echo on a live call

Echo works with Cisco Unified CM, Cisco Emergency Responder, Microsoft Teams Direct Routing and Cisco BroadWorks, with no software to install.

See how Pinpoint works on your property

9Line Pinpoint draws geofences around your buildings, detects cellular 911 calls made inside them and tells your on-site team which building and approximate floor the call came from.

Make your phone system 911 compliant

9Line Dispatch sends a dispatchable location with every 911 call and alerts on-site staff the moment 911 is dialed, for Microsoft Teams, Cisco UCM, Cisco BroadWorks and Cisco Emergency Responder.

Talk to a 911 compliance specialist

Tell us about your property and phone system, and we will show you where 9Line Pinpoint and 9Line Dispatch fit.